Difference between Online UPS and Offline UPS
Difference between Online UPS and Offline UPS
UPS, Uninterruptible Power Supply is a device that supplies power in case of power failures. A UPS can be either Online UPS or Offline UPS. Both types of UPS can be used as a backup power source but there are many differences between them.
The major point that differentiates between the online UPS and offline UPS is that the online UPS supplies power from the AC mains to the Load through the rectifier and inverter combination while the Offline UPS directly supplies power from AC mains to the load. Before going to the list of differences between Online UPS and Offline UPS, let’s discuss the basics of Online UPS and Offline UPS.
What is UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply)?
UPS is an abbreviation for Uninterruptible Power Supply and the reason for its name is that it provides a constant supply of power without any interruption. In Normal operation, it draws current from the AC mains, and during a power outage; it draws current from its backup source.
A UPS system utilizes DC power stored in the battery as its backup source. The UPS charges the battery from the AC mains through a Rectifier and charge controller circuit. At the same time, it supplies power to the output AC load. In case of power failure, the UPS utilizes this charged DC power in the battery and converts it into AC using an inverter and supplies it to the AC load.
Now the switch over between the sources (AC mains and the battery in case of power failure) is instantaneous. But it does take some time. This time delay during the switching may affect some sensitive electronic equipment while other devices may tolerate it in a specific range. This is where Online UPS and Offline UPS comes into play.
What is Online UPS?
Online UPS is a type of UPS that supplies power to the AC load through the Rectifier and Inverter Combo in normal operation and uses an inverter to supply AC power during a power failure. Therefore, the output power supply always stays ON and there is no need for switching. Hence, there is no time delay in switching between its sources. There is no interruption in the case of power failure even for a nanosecond.
During normal operation, it converts the AC supply from the AC mains into DC using a rectifier and charges the battery using a charge controller circuit. Now at the same time, the DC power from the charged battery is being converted into AC using an inverter to supply it to the output AC load.
In case of power failure, the UPS will stop drawing current from the AC mains and stops charging the battery. But the AC load will continuously draw current from the battery through the Inverter.
Therefore, Online UPS has a zero time delay when switching its power source. It is also why it is known as Online UPS because it stays ON even during its normal operation.
Since the current drawn by the AC load is continuously flowing through its whole circuit, the temperature of the system increases. Therefore, it needs comparatively larger heat sinks and components that can withstand high temperatures and it can tolerate current flow for a very long duration. Due to such a requirement, the cost of Online UPS increases significantly.
It continuously draws current from the battery which quickly reduces the lifetime of the battery compared to offline UPS. They are more inefficient because they continuously stay ON even in normal operation.
On the other hand, it does offer high-quality output because there is no gap during the switching between the source supplies. It completely isolates the output from the AC mains. Therefore, it helps in protection against the distortions or fluctuations in the AC mains.
What are Offline UPS?
The offline UPS is a type of UPS that directly supplies the power to the AC load from the AC mains in normal operation and uses an inverter to power the AC load from the DC battery. Since there are two separate lines of supplies, the output supply must be switched between the two sources.
The switching speed of an Offline UPS is around 5ms which is enough to keep a computer from shutting down. But not fast enough to keep a smooth operation of sensitive equipment in hospitals.
During normal operation, the power from AC mains is directly supplied to the output through a static transfer switch. At the same time, the AC is converted into DC using a rectifier to charge the battery using a charge controller. But unlike Online UPS, the inverter does not draw current from the battery until the primary supply (AC main) is interrupted.
When the primary supply breaks, the battery stops charging, and the static switch transfers the output line to the inverter side very quickly. At the same time, the inverter starts drawing current from the battery which is then supplied to the AC load.
Since it stays off when it draws current from the AC line during normal operation, it is known as Offline UPS.
The Offline UPS mostly stays off in normal operation and because of that, the temperature of the components stays low. Therefore, it requires smaller heat sinks and the components with a lower tolerance can be used which also decreases the overall cost of the offline UPS.
Since it stays off in its normal operation and does not use the battery continuously, the efficiency of the system increases.
But the downside of offline UPS is that the directly supplied AC is not completely isolated from the load. Therefore, there is no protection between the load and source and the distortion or fluctuations in the Ac mains can damage the connected load.
Differences between Online UPS and Offline UPS
|The UPS that supplies power from the AC mains to the load through the rectifier and inverter combination
|The UPS that supply the AC mains power directly to the load.
|It continuously draws current from the battery.
|It only draws current from the battery during primary source failure or power outage.
|It requires a large battery charger circuit because it carries the entire load current.
|It requires a small charger circuit because it only charges the battery.
|The input supply and the load is completely isolated.
|There is no isolation between the input supply and the load.
|It has high-performance output because it protects the output load from input voltage spike and distortion.
|Its performance reduces with the input voltage distortion; which is directly connected to the load.
|There is not switching between the source, hence no time delay
|It uses a static transfer switch to switch between its source with a time delay of 5ms
|It stays ON almost at all times.
|It turns ON only at power failure.
|Due to its continuous ON condition, it is inefficient and unreliable.
|It is more efficient and reliable because it mostly stays off.
|It requires large heat sinks because of the high operating temperature
|It requires smaller heat sinks because of low operating temperature due to its off state mostly.
|The components used must have the tolerance to withstand high temperature
|There is no need for the components to have high-temperature tolerance.
|It is expensive than Offline UPS.
|It is cheaper than Online UPS.
|It is used for very sensitive electronics that cannot tolerate any gap between supplies such as in-hospital ICUs
|Offline UPS is used for electronic equipment that can tolerate a delay of 5ms such as Computer etc
Which one to Use, Online or Offline UPS & Why?
Is online or offline UPS Better? and When to use it? it totally depends on multiple factors such as cost, usage, and specific conditions, etc. For example,
When to Use Online UPS:
- When to operate the sensitive and important devices and equipment with continuous power supply without switching operations.
- When the main power supply fluctuates frequently or daily scheduled load shading and power outage.
- When there are no concerns about the operation, installation, and maintenance cost as the online UPS system is costly than the offline UPS system due to the additional parts in the online uninterruptible power supply.
- When you need the simultaneous operation of connected devices for a longer time duration.
When to Use Offline UPS:
- When cost is the major and considerable factor.
- When switching is not a big issue i.e. you are OK to use it with auto or manual change-over or transfer switch between main power, portable generator or emergency generator set, solar or battery power.
The conclusion of this article showing the key difference between ONLINE & OFFLINE UPS systems is that the online UPS has zero time delay between the switching and they are expensive. while the Offline UPS has a time delay of 5ms but they are inexpensive. Based on efficiency, the offline UPS is far better than Online UPS and it should be used for domestic purposes. Online UPS should be only used for very sensitive electronic equipment.